This place was highly recommended to us by a friend so we had to check it out.
We visited on a Friday night and we did not have to wait for a table, we were seated immediately.
They had a high chair for my toddler daughter which I mention because a couple of NYC restaurants we visited did not have highchairs.
I ordered the lobster pasta. I can't remember the menu name but it was good! It was a smaller portion than I expected but in reality, it was just the right amount, I didn't get too full.
We also ordered the calamari for an appetizer. I wasn't blown away, it didn't have much flavor to me. I wish I would have gotten the lobster Mac n Cheese.
My fiance ordered the burger and lobster and he enjoyed his meal. He said he's glad he got the whole instead of the half because it wouldn't have been enough.
Our waiter was very friendly, she made sure we had everything we didn't and the establishment was very clean from what I saw.
PCC TV
-
December 18, 2023
Burger & Lobster have remained consistent through the years of its inception. I mean every table had the Combo meal. Why come to Burger & Lobster and not have a Burger & a Lobster. The music, the decor the service all fits together well. There perfect balance allows me to feel and taste the wonderful flavors of the juicy burger as I dip my lobster in the garlic butter for a very smooth taste.,
And there is no hesitation refilling my table of 3 glasses of coke & water.
Amir Durrani
-
November 20, 2023
Never had a bad experience here. I came here 7 years ago, 6 years ago, and finally, once again, today. Their food quality is always consistent. The waiters are great and check up on ya. Burger was cooked perfectly. Lobster was fire. I think they make their pickles in house cuz they are unique and full of flavor. Well priced, great ambiance, love everything about this place.
T.R. Dailey
-
December 11, 2022
Delicious food and chill environment. They really allow the lobster to stand on its own, with the additional flavors being subtle. The pear necessity (the drink) was lovely, the flavors enhancing the gin, and the madison park punch (not pictured) was minty and sublime. Amazing service, we had an 18mo with us and they traded out her chair when we needed it and even conversed with her to get her "order". Super cute.
Tim
-
November 02, 2023
4 years later and still 5*. I'm back (again!) for my birthday for one of the 'big boys' to celebrate. Wonderful experience, delicious drinks, amazing lobster, and wonderful staff. Big shout-out to the staff for taking great care of us - totally unexpected but greatly appreciated.
So glad to see this chain made its way over from London! (especially since their lobsters are all from Maine anyhow)
We caught it on a slower weekend night thanks to some rain, otherwise expect a wait. It’s worth it though.
They know their stuff when it comes to lobster - the 2lb dinner deal for $45 is where it’s at. Nice big lobster, split and steamed perfectly. Their garlic butter is a great compliment, though they also have plain butter for the traditionalists out there. I’ve had the burger elsewhere and can also highly recommend that for those who don’t like seafood but got dragged along :) it’s tasty and not just a generic burger.
Considering it’s a lobster dinner, the prices are very reasonable...and you have the splurge option for some of the huge 5+ pound monsters. I did ask, and they actually take care of their lobsters, too, with responsible sourcing and feeding them properly. Ever wonder why you got a lobster that seemed empty inside despite a hard shell? They held it too long and didn’t feed it. Not a problem here, thankfully.
Our Address
39 W 19th St, New York, NY 10011, USA
Claim Listing: Burger & Lobster Flatiron
Please Login or Register an Account to Claim Listing
This place was highly recommended to us by a friend so we had to check it out. We visited on a Friday night and we did not have to wait for a table, we were seated immediately. They had a high chair for my toddler daughter which I mention because a couple of NYC restaurants we visited did not have highchairs. I ordered the lobster pasta. I can't remember the menu name but it was good! It was a smaller portion than I expected but in reality, it was just the right amount, I didn't get too full. We also ordered the calamari for an appetizer. I wasn't blown away, it didn't have much flavor to me. I wish I would have gotten the lobster Mac n Cheese. My fiance ordered the burger and lobster and he enjoyed his meal. He said he's glad he got the whole instead of the half because it wouldn't have been enough. Our waiter was very friendly, she made sure we had everything we didn't and the establishment was very clean from what I saw.
Burger & Lobster have remained consistent through the years of its inception. I mean every table had the Combo meal. Why come to Burger & Lobster and not have a Burger & a Lobster. The music, the decor the service all fits together well. There perfect balance allows me to feel and taste the wonderful flavors of the juicy burger as I dip my lobster in the garlic butter for a very smooth taste., And there is no hesitation refilling my table of 3 glasses of coke & water.
Never had a bad experience here. I came here 7 years ago, 6 years ago, and finally, once again, today. Their food quality is always consistent. The waiters are great and check up on ya. Burger was cooked perfectly. Lobster was fire. I think they make their pickles in house cuz they are unique and full of flavor. Well priced, great ambiance, love everything about this place.
Delicious food and chill environment. They really allow the lobster to stand on its own, with the additional flavors being subtle. The pear necessity (the drink) was lovely, the flavors enhancing the gin, and the madison park punch (not pictured) was minty and sublime. Amazing service, we had an 18mo with us and they traded out her chair when we needed it and even conversed with her to get her "order". Super cute.
4 years later and still 5*. I'm back (again!) for my birthday for one of the 'big boys' to celebrate. Wonderful experience, delicious drinks, amazing lobster, and wonderful staff. Big shout-out to the staff for taking great care of us - totally unexpected but greatly appreciated. So glad to see this chain made its way over from London! (especially since their lobsters are all from Maine anyhow) We caught it on a slower weekend night thanks to some rain, otherwise expect a wait. It’s worth it though. They know their stuff when it comes to lobster - the 2lb dinner deal for $45 is where it’s at. Nice big lobster, split and steamed perfectly. Their garlic butter is a great compliment, though they also have plain butter for the traditionalists out there. I’ve had the burger elsewhere and can also highly recommend that for those who don’t like seafood but got dragged along :) it’s tasty and not just a generic burger. Considering it’s a lobster dinner, the prices are very reasonable...and you have the splurge option for some of the huge 5+ pound monsters. I did ask, and they actually take care of their lobsters, too, with responsible sourcing and feeding them properly. Ever wonder why you got a lobster that seemed empty inside despite a hard shell? They held it too long and didn’t feed it. Not a problem here, thankfully.