Casa Carmen Flatiron

5 W 21st St, New York, NY 10010, USA

About Casa Carmen Flatiron

4.7 / 5

from reviews

    Yiannis Psaroudis
    -
    June 03, 2024

    As my boyfriend is Mexican, I am constantly on the hunt for good date night places that will remind him of the authentic flavours of home, so I was delighted to "discover" Casa Carmen, for his recent birthdate. The restaurant is absolutely beautiful, the food was delicious & the service was top-notch.I had the guava frozen margarita—which, to my surprise, actually tasted of guava; guava is such a subtle flavour & I am often disappointed by its presentation in cocktails, but not this time—the guacamole, the enmoladas Xico & the pastel de elote &, while everything was top-notch, I can't say enough about the pastel de elote! This is going to sound weird, but if you're a fan of sparkling water—I consider myself a bit of a sparking water sommelier—the B'ui is not to be missed; it's one of the best I've ever had.

    HANE Xxxx
    -
    October 06, 2023

    Very authentic mexican food and elevated ambiance. I was with a group of Mexican friends and they were very impressed with dishes which are not very common in American Mexican restaurants. I loved the octopus with rice. The desserts and cocktails were especially good. And the service was very kind, prompt and gracious.

    Chip Brian
    -
    November 09, 2023

    This place is the spot you got to come see Ramiro at the bar.... Excellent food, wonderful people. A great atmosphere. Don't miss it.. A big thanks to Luis and chef Ivan.. We went on a culinary adventure tonight that we did not expect and it was excellent. Highly recommended. Do not miss the opportunity here to have the corn cake, dessert or the pibil... Wow, what a treat!!!

    toffy concepcion
    -
    July 14, 2023

    This Mexican inspired restaurant has excellent ceviche and drinks. They have a thick corn chip like a tostada that you can top with shrimp, fresh fish or crab as a ceviche. The drinks are excellent and original because they use smokey mezcal instead of tequila. The cactus cooler, banana old fashioned, mezcal straight. Great service too.

    James L
    -
    August 09, 2023

    Came here for dinner. I like the decoration, ambience and the low noise level. Ordered two dishes from the “to share” section (Ceviche verde and Tostadas de cangrejo), one from the “main course” (Enchiladas verdes) and one from the “dessert” (Pastel de elote). I like the two from the “to share”, as well as the dessert. But not so much for the main, as I feel it a bit over-priced. The flavor is good though.

    Casa Carmen Flatiron

    Our Address

    5 W 21st St, New York, NY 10010, USA

    Get Listed Today!

    Are you interested in being listed on our site? Click the button to fill in your details today!