Pisillo Italian Panini Chelsea

124 W 25th St, New York, NY 10001, USA

About Pisillo Italian Panini Chelsea

4.8 / 5

from reviews

    Scott Laine
    April 30, 2023

    I heard about this sandwich spot from a Italian Vespa mechanic in Queens so it had a level of credibility about it even before I showed up. The first thing you notice is that it is a small place but the music is mighty. I felt like I walked into a nightclub, but in a good way. Like in Naples you have to move fast because that’s how things are done. First choose your bread, if you didn’t choose your sandwich already take a big step back and figure it out. No clue because all 35 of them look great? No problem do what I did. Ask the guy if you should get this one or that one. Done. We got the Verona and the Genoa. Both were huge! They weighed 2lbs each. No really I weighed them. I think the rock star move here is to order 3 or 4 sandwiches for 5-7 people and have them slice each sandwich into four sections. Size and weight aside both were amazing. The bread is great the deli is great and the flavor combinations felt so authentic. Only thing missing is a post lunch dip in the Adriatic.

    Tyler Colburn
    June 30, 2022

    This place is legit! Like “from Italy with love” legit! This sandwich shop is exactly what I’d expect of an amazing, traditional New York Italian sandwich shop - no frills, Italian pride, and good quality ingredients. Plenty of bread, meat and cheese options. Good quality meats and cheeses and fresh bread made by a Brooklyn establishment that’s been around 30+ years. The amount of meat and cheese they put on their sandwiches is crazy! They load it up - I couldn’t even finish my sandwich, and I eat a lot! The guys working at the shop were extremely nice and friendly to everyone that entered. I got several smiles while eating my sandwich! While I was eating my delicious sandwich, a girl who works a couple shops over came in just to order a bottle of water and they just gave it to her and told her to cover it next time (because she didn’t have any cash). That’s true customer service and just good ol’ hospitality. This place is worth a visit! I’ll definitely be returning, to support a local, small business, and also to try another one of their amazing sandwiches.

    July 24, 2023

    I decided to try this place as it was next door to our hotel. I was in a pizza coma so I needed to try something different. The sandwich was excellent. They cut prosciutto fresh to order the buffalo mozzarella was good this sandwich needed a kick some spice. They also have the Italian San Carlo chips and the San Benedetto green ice tea. Very good panino #sangwich

    Anthony Mastrogiulio
    June 06, 2023

    Stop reading, start eating. This is the best value you’ll get for lunch from Chelsea to FiDi. Under $20, 15”+ sandwich, all imported Italian meats and breads. No frills, walk-in, order, pay, get sandwich, leave. No need to over complicate perfection.

    October 22, 2022

    I ordered n.26 and it literally blew my mind. Firstly, I was surprised about the size(I bet nobody can eat it up at once), Secondly, the taste is super insane. Bread was very right crispy and the prosciutto and cheese was so savory. It was my best sandwich ever in Manhattan.

    Pisillo Italian Panini Chelsea

    Our Address

    124 W 25th St, New York, NY 10001, USA

    Get Listed Today!

    Are you interested in being listed on our site? Click the button to fill in your details today!