Two bars in one really. One at the front, with it's own door, and one at the rear, with outside seating area too, and access into the Fitzpatrick hotel lobby.
It's a great bar. Both bars make one pub!
But I want to talk about breakfast.
If you didn't know it before, you do now: the Irish know a thing or two about doing a great cooked breakfast.
Go for the full Irish breakfast - you won't be disappointed. Combine that with cosy surroundings, attention to detail (everything is quality, proper butter, good marmalade, lovely bacon, and delicious black pudding and white pudding), and then add supremely friendly, confident, and professional service, and you have a winner.
John Ng
-
April 05, 2026
Had lunch here and it was a great experience overall. Great spot for well-priced bar food with fast service. The staff is very friendly and attentive, which adds to the welcoming atmosphere. The place has a warm, authentic Irish pub feel that makes it a comfortable spot to relax and enjoy a meal.
The food tastes great, with solid portions and classic pub favorites done right. Everything came out quickly, which is a big plus. Overall a great spot for a busy city, would definitely recommend.
mneadle
-
February 19, 2026
This little place has great energy! I was staying at Fitzpatrick Hotel next door (I think they own it - that’s what my receipt says). So I’m not a regular and don’t know if it’s always like this but on both the day and Wednesday nights the crowd was fairly large for a small pub and noise level was high. People enjoy libations and chatter. Restaurant seemed pretty full too. I stopped in for a simple to go order to bring to my room in the hotel. It was cold so I felt like a bowl of soup. Beef stroganoff was their soup of the day so I ordered it. I wasn’t overly excited about stroganoff and when I opened it even less so it was like oil and water that wouldn’t mix. I literally stirred it before each spoonful. But guess what? It grew on me and WAS really good!! Beef cubes, fresh mushrooms and onions and a belly warming broth. Hit the spot even though I was reluctant.
Maddie _
-
December 23, 2025
Been here twice now, the first was for food, ordered the Irish breakfast expecting a great Irish breakfast not what I got, looked a bit pitiful for a proper Irish breakfast.
Hate the fact you have to tip when the waitress looks anything but happy to be serving you.
Second occasion called for a pint, not bad, good atmosphere, the ladies on the bar were very polite.
Kandace Sanders
-
June 09, 2026
I went for an after work happy hour. The patio was packed, but in a good way. Also, the music was rockingggg lol. I didn't expect them to play as much hip hop & R&B as they did. I'm talking deep cuts lol. Overall good energy. The apps were good. Only had beer but the cocktails looked good as well.
Our Address
141 E 44th St, New York, NY 10017, USA
Claim Listing: The Wheeltapper Pub
Please Login or Register an Account to Claim Listing
Two bars in one really. One at the front, with it's own door, and one at the rear, with outside seating area too, and access into the Fitzpatrick hotel lobby. It's a great bar. Both bars make one pub! But I want to talk about breakfast. If you didn't know it before, you do now: the Irish know a thing or two about doing a great cooked breakfast. Go for the full Irish breakfast - you won't be disappointed. Combine that with cosy surroundings, attention to detail (everything is quality, proper butter, good marmalade, lovely bacon, and delicious black pudding and white pudding), and then add supremely friendly, confident, and professional service, and you have a winner.
Had lunch here and it was a great experience overall. Great spot for well-priced bar food with fast service. The staff is very friendly and attentive, which adds to the welcoming atmosphere. The place has a warm, authentic Irish pub feel that makes it a comfortable spot to relax and enjoy a meal. The food tastes great, with solid portions and classic pub favorites done right. Everything came out quickly, which is a big plus. Overall a great spot for a busy city, would definitely recommend.
This little place has great energy! I was staying at Fitzpatrick Hotel next door (I think they own it - that’s what my receipt says). So I’m not a regular and don’t know if it’s always like this but on both the day and Wednesday nights the crowd was fairly large for a small pub and noise level was high. People enjoy libations and chatter. Restaurant seemed pretty full too. I stopped in for a simple to go order to bring to my room in the hotel. It was cold so I felt like a bowl of soup. Beef stroganoff was their soup of the day so I ordered it. I wasn’t overly excited about stroganoff and when I opened it even less so it was like oil and water that wouldn’t mix. I literally stirred it before each spoonful. But guess what? It grew on me and WAS really good!! Beef cubes, fresh mushrooms and onions and a belly warming broth. Hit the spot even though I was reluctant.
Been here twice now, the first was for food, ordered the Irish breakfast expecting a great Irish breakfast not what I got, looked a bit pitiful for a proper Irish breakfast. Hate the fact you have to tip when the waitress looks anything but happy to be serving you. Second occasion called for a pint, not bad, good atmosphere, the ladies on the bar were very polite.
I went for an after work happy hour. The patio was packed, but in a good way. Also, the music was rockingggg lol. I didn't expect them to play as much hip hop & R&B as they did. I'm talking deep cuts lol. Overall good energy. The apps were good. Only had beer but the cocktails looked good as well.