I’m almost sure I had already written a review for Zaytinya because I truly love this place, but I couldn’t find it — so here I go again.
This time I visited for lunch (for a friend’s birthday), and the previous time I came for dinner (my anniversary). Both experiences were absolutely incredible.
The food has a truly authentic Turkish and Mediterranean flavor, and I genuinely love their menu. The Adana Kebab is outstanding — perfectly seasoned, full of flavor, and beautifully prepared. Portions feel just right, prices are fair, and everything tastes high quality.
The service is also a huge part of what makes this place special: the attention is professional, the staff is kind and attentive, and they’re very thoughtful with every detail. It feels luxurious without being stiff — the ambiance is relaxed and welcoming, which I really appreciate.
Even after finishing our lunch, we ended up coming back later for a drink at the bar, simply because we enjoy the space so much.
Highly recommended.
Olivia Scioletti
-
March 09, 2026
Can’t thank the team at Zaytinya enough for such a wonderful birthday dinner experience! I emailed with the team literally the day before my event, and they pulled together a customized menu and seating for 14 people in the center of the restaurant. The food was fantastic and the service was excellent!
Perfect spot for a group event or any dinner date.✨
Farah Ballesteros
-
June 09, 2026
Every time I come to Zaytinya, I’m reminded why I keep finding reasons to come back!!
Angie, Michelle, and Tristan set the tone the second you walk through the door, making you feel like you’re exactly where you’re supposed to be.
From there, the service never misses. If someone isn’t making sure your glass stays full, there’s a good chance fresh bread is headed your way. The attention to detail is unreal.
Chris and Issa were wonderful as always, but a special shoutout to my servers, Jacob and Ricardo, who took incredible care of us throughout the meal. And the bar team? Estaban*, Antonio, and Wilson are in a league of their own. . . . every cocktail is executed flawlessly!
What stands out most is how seamless the experience feels from beginning to end. Every person on this team contributes to an atmosphere that makes dining here feel special without ever feeling forced.
Safe to say I’m still not tired of spending my money at Zaytinya. 10/10 experience, every single time. Part of me wants to gatekeep it, but places this good deserve the recognition. ❤️🍸🥖✨
Traci Grover
-
July 09, 2026
What a fun experience at Zaytinya! The tasting menu + wine pairing were exceptional. The only thing that didn’t hold up was the falafel. The shrimp was something I will dream about and the lamb was perfection. They have an a very knowledgeable sommelier, John, who introduced me to wines from counties I’ve never tried before.
Ali Salman
-
April 06, 2026
Everything we had was amazing! I’ve now tried all of the Jose Andres restaurants/bars in this building and I’ve gotta say this is maybe my favorite! Quality was top notch and it’s hard to find good soujuk so I had to get that and do recommend that to share. All the mains from lamb to beef to salmon are great too and staff is kind, professional and attentive!
Our Address
1185 Broadway, New York, NY 10001, USA
Claim Listing: Zaytinya
Please Login or Register an Account to Claim Listing
I’m almost sure I had already written a review for Zaytinya because I truly love this place, but I couldn’t find it — so here I go again. This time I visited for lunch (for a friend’s birthday), and the previous time I came for dinner (my anniversary). Both experiences were absolutely incredible. The food has a truly authentic Turkish and Mediterranean flavor, and I genuinely love their menu. The Adana Kebab is outstanding — perfectly seasoned, full of flavor, and beautifully prepared. Portions feel just right, prices are fair, and everything tastes high quality. The service is also a huge part of what makes this place special: the attention is professional, the staff is kind and attentive, and they’re very thoughtful with every detail. It feels luxurious without being stiff — the ambiance is relaxed and welcoming, which I really appreciate. Even after finishing our lunch, we ended up coming back later for a drink at the bar, simply because we enjoy the space so much. Highly recommended.
Can’t thank the team at Zaytinya enough for such a wonderful birthday dinner experience! I emailed with the team literally the day before my event, and they pulled together a customized menu and seating for 14 people in the center of the restaurant. The food was fantastic and the service was excellent! Perfect spot for a group event or any dinner date.✨
Every time I come to Zaytinya, I’m reminded why I keep finding reasons to come back!! Angie, Michelle, and Tristan set the tone the second you walk through the door, making you feel like you’re exactly where you’re supposed to be. From there, the service never misses. If someone isn’t making sure your glass stays full, there’s a good chance fresh bread is headed your way. The attention to detail is unreal. Chris and Issa were wonderful as always, but a special shoutout to my servers, Jacob and Ricardo, who took incredible care of us throughout the meal. And the bar team? Estaban*, Antonio, and Wilson are in a league of their own. . . . every cocktail is executed flawlessly! What stands out most is how seamless the experience feels from beginning to end. Every person on this team contributes to an atmosphere that makes dining here feel special without ever feeling forced. Safe to say I’m still not tired of spending my money at Zaytinya. 10/10 experience, every single time. Part of me wants to gatekeep it, but places this good deserve the recognition. ❤️🍸🥖✨
What a fun experience at Zaytinya! The tasting menu + wine pairing were exceptional. The only thing that didn’t hold up was the falafel. The shrimp was something I will dream about and the lamb was perfection. They have an a very knowledgeable sommelier, John, who introduced me to wines from counties I’ve never tried before.
Everything we had was amazing! I’ve now tried all of the Jose Andres restaurants/bars in this building and I’ve gotta say this is maybe my favorite! Quality was top notch and it’s hard to find good soujuk so I had to get that and do recommend that to share. All the mains from lamb to beef to salmon are great too and staff is kind, professional and attentive!