Burger & Lobster Flatiron

39 W 19th St, New York, NY 10011, USA

About Burger & Lobster Flatiron

4.4 / 5

from reviews

    Shani B.
    January 31, 2024

    First time at this restaurant, would go again! The apps were delicious! Came in on a Saturday evening at the start of dinner rush. What was weird, was that we were told we had to wait a few minutes (completely fine) but we were not asked to give our name. That did make it a hassle when the time came to start seating parties. But after about 20 minutes, were we able to get seated. The fried calamari was some of the best I’ve had. The crab bites had a kick, but were still flavorful. There were three in my party and we all had the same entree. The only difference was that I got a boiled lobster with the lemon garlic butter. The butter had a weird texture, but also, I’m not sure if I am a lobster fan. Still a great dish, but personally, I would just get the burger and fries. I would have preferred a brioche bun instead of the seeded. But the homemade pickles and the fries were amazing! Also, the La Paloma margarita were delicious and definitely worth a second round.

    Kevin Beck
    March 09, 2024

    Best happy hour in the city! My wife and I were in NYC for a weekend and we loved Burger & Lobster so much, we came back a second time. The happy hour menu is priced very reasonably and the quality of food and drinks you get really stood out to us. Our barman Noah really took care of us, making sure to refresh our mojitos as we emptied them. He was an absolute pleasure and really was one of the highlights of our trip. The food.. oh god the food, where do I start. Let me just say that they know how to make a Burger, and the blackened shrimp tacos were dynamite. They had such a nice kick to them, seasoned wonderfully and were the most perfect bites. There's a reason we had like 10 orders of them in two days ! My wife still dreams about them. Noah, if you see this review, thank you so much. We hope to see you when we come back. Burger & Lobster staff really know how to keep the good times rolling.

    Dixie S
    February 26, 2024

    We were there on Valentine's Day, arrived too late and missed our slot, but the welcome was very nice and they still tried to seat us quickly: Sorry and thank you for that! Our waitress at the table tried hard, but wasn't quite as good as the one at the next table. The ice cubes we ordered only arrived when the drink was already empty and the fries were unfortunately only warm. The lobster tongs were missing. We would have liked to have said something, but the waiter simply didn't come for a long time, which we thought was a shame. It was really busy, but we would have appreciated a little more attention. All in all, 4 stars and a little room for improvement!

    Marissa Citarell
    February 12, 2024

    I am so glad that this place is now on my radar. Anytime I need to go to the city for work, with friends, or family I will always recommend this place for dinner. The options are very limited (to lobster and burgers of course) but if you vet out who you’re bringing to make sure that’s alright I guarantee they’ll have an amazing time. Brought my boyfriend who had the wagyu burger and said it was the best burger he has ever had. All around a great spot!

    Amir Durrani
    November 20, 2023

    Never had a bad experience here. I came here 7 years ago, 6 years ago, and finally, once again, today. Their food quality is always consistent. The waiters are great and check up on ya. Burger was cooked perfectly. Lobster was fire. I think they make their pickles in house cuz they are unique and full of flavor. Well priced, great ambiance, love everything about this place.

    Burger & Lobster Flatiron

    Our Address

    39 W 19th St, New York, NY 10011, USA

    Get Listed Today!

    Are you interested in being listed on our site? Click the button to fill in your details today!