Eataly NYC Flatiron

200 5th Ave, New York, NY 10010, USA

About Eataly NYC Flatiron

4.5 / 5

from reviews

    Katie Boudreau
    July 11, 2024

    Fun spot that is mostly grocery store than restaurant. Hidden in the very back you’ll find their pizza and pasta restaurant. Waitstaff was friendly and attentive. We arrived a little after 5pm and were told we needed to finish by 6:15pm since they’d need our table. We thankfully finished on time, but you could see come dessert time they were getting ready to rush us a bit. Food was good, vibes were nice, and the Italian cola was delicious.

    Slava Z
    July 05, 2024

    Throughout our trip to New York we went here for breakfast, excellent sandwiches, fresh and tasty, the coffee is generally great. But the tastiest thing is the ice cream, beyond all praise. Thank you, I will recommend it to everyone.

    Eugene Lee
    April 06, 2024

    Eataly in New York brought that familiar "bring Italy to your home" vibe I've come to know and love from their locations worldwide. There's something comforting about the consistency in their theme, no matter where you are. I'll admit, stepping into the New York store, my expectations were sky-high, secretly hoping it would dwarf the one back in Toronto with its grandeur. While it may not have stretched the square footage as I imagined, the experience was not to be underestimated. What struck me most was the meticulous layout of each department, a thoughtful design and an understanding of the customer journey. Navigating through the aisles felt effortless, almost intuitive, allowing for a leisurely exploration of Italian culinary delights. It’s this ease of browsing, the seamless transition from one section to another, that elevates the shopping experience beyond just the physical space it occupies.

    Wim May
    June 30, 2024

    A substantial force in exotic produce and imported pastas - though the employees seem disinterested, and the layout excessively complex. There’s repeat items in a lot of areas - it is wild that they’ve opted to fill the store with duplicates rather than have distinct areas. Rent can’t be cheap. They must be making bank. It’s a pity the cheeses are priced for Americans, but the produce - whew. They’ve got some things I’ve never seen at farm markets or specialty greengrocers. They get their stars for sourcing quality goods - but I’d love to see the concept better executed and the staff more invested.

    Nancy Dibert
    February 17, 2024

    We stopped by on Super Bowl Sunday to grab a few things to have for the game. As always, the selection of cheese and Italian meats was superior. We purchased several loaves of fresh bread. The focaccia was tasteless but the traditional was crusty and tasty. Both needed more salt to the dough. Disappointed in the cotton candy grapes as they were soft and lifeless. Purchased a raspberry nougat on the way out and it was absolutely incredible. Love the live music and the restaurant offerings. Hate walking through the seafood section, though, as the fishy smell gets to me. Don’t miss the fresh pasta, though!

    Eataly NYC Flatiron

    Our Address

    200 5th Ave, New York, NY 10010, USA

    Get Listed Today!

    Are you interested in being listed on our site? Click the button to fill in your details today!